A Gentle Rebellion on a Dessert Plate

I used to think rebellion had to be loud. I believed it needed raised voices, dramatic exits, or choices so big they announced themselves the moment they were made. Courage, I thought, only counted if it looked impressive from the outside.

That day proved me wrong.

I was standing in front of a glass display filled with desserts when my eyes paused on a slice of carrot cake. It caught my attention in a way the others did not. The slice seemed to linger in my line of sight, quietly inviting, as if asking me to consider it. I hesitated, doubt rising almost immediately. What if I did not like it? What if I regretted choosing it? And then another thought followed, softer but steadier. Why not try?

I had always been the kind of person who chose what I already knew would not disappoint me. Not because I lacked curiosity, but because disappointment had taught me caution. After missing the mark enough times, you learn to narrow your choices. After enough mess, you learn how to protect yourself.

Carrot cake had never been my first choice. Choosing it felt unnecessary, almost impractical. Why risk liking something unfamiliar when comfort was already proven and waiting? But something in me was tired of choosing comfort that felt more like avoidance. Tired of letting fear dress itself up as wisdom.

So I ordered the carrot cake.

It was a small decision, almost laughably small. No one around me noticed. There was no applause, no pause in the world. Yet something shifted quietly inside me. For once, I had not asked myself what was safest. I had asked what felt honest in that moment.

When the fork sank into the cake, the bite was soft and spiced, imperfect in a way that felt human. The sweetness did not overwhelm. The texture was uneven. It did not try too hard to be liked. It simply existed as it was, and somehow, in that moment, so did I.

As I ate, I realized how much I had been shrinking my choices beneath all my misses and messes. I had called it maturity. I had called it wisdom. I had called it self-protection. But it was also fear. Fear of choosing wrong again. Fear of disappointment. Fear of confirming the quiet voice that says I do not always get things right.

That slice of carrot cake was not really about dessert. It was about allowing myself to choose differently without needing to explain it. It was about letting a small want matter. It was about trusting myself with something low stakes, simply because I could.

Maybe healing does not begin with fixing the mess. Maybe it begins beneath it, in the small, almost invisible rebellions. In choosing what we usually ignore. In saying yes to something unfamiliar without needing it to make sense to anyone else.

After so many misses, it is easy to forget that we are still allowed to choose again. After so much mess, it is easy to forget that gentleness can also be brave.

That day, my rebellion was quiet. It did not change my life or solve anything. But it reminded me that I am still capable of choosing for myself, even in small ways, even when no one is watching.

That day, I ordered carrot cake.

And it tasted like freedom, sweet, spiced, and just the slightest bit terrifying. - MESSY E.

💌 Subscribe to Miss and Mess
A journal of reflections, resilience, and the quiet power of living through life’s misses and messes.
Scroll below and hit “Yes to the Mess” — and never miss a post.